Best Auto Insurance Companies

Drivers should assess their coverage needs prior to shopping for car insurance. Liability coverage is usually mandatory while comprehensive is usually recommended.

Drivers require more than just competitive rates when it comes to insurance – they also want excellent customer support, including an easy claims process and responsive agents. Our comparison analysis took into account customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power and AM Best as well as complaint ratio with state insurance commissioners.

1. Geico

GEICO stands out in our analysis of car insurance providers by offering affordable rates and stellar customer service, which earned it top position. Their mobile app makes getting quotes, buying policies and managing coverage simple – not to mention discounts for using your vehicle’s safety features and joining certain organizations!

Geico offers a solid range of coverage options, such as roadside assistance and rental reimbursement. However, its biggest weakness lies in customer reviews on popular review sites like Trustpilot or BBB that often complain of claim processing issues or poor service; furthermore GEICO does not offer gap or rideshare insurance plans.

2. Metromile

Metromile provides pay-per-mile insurance in eight states, making it an attractive choice for drivers who cover large mileage distances as it tends to be much more cost effective than standard auto policies.

To calculate your quote, the company provides you with a device called Pulse that plugs into the OBD-II diagnostic port on your vehicle – usually found under the dashboard and adjacent to the steering wheel). Once connected, you can view your driving data through Metromile app that also lets you customize coverage, view cards or policy documents, decode check engine lights if they appear, track down stolen vehicles and file claims.

Telematics-driven pricing provides drivers with more accurate quotes by giving less consideration to non-driving factors like age, credit and driving history, while handling claims internally. Ideal if your driving range covers between 12,000-18,000 miles annually; roadside assistance services add another convenient layer.

3. Auto-Owners

Auto-Owners ranks high on our 2023 list of best car insurers due to its competitive rates, comprehensive selection of coverage options and special offerings like personal diminished value and rental car coverage. In addition, it boasts few consumer complaints among comparable-sized insurers and an A++ financial strength rating from AM Best.

Auto-Owners provides auto policies in most states at rates up to 16% cheaper than average for full coverage policies. Furthermore, this company offers accident forgiveness that keeps your rate low after one at-fault accident.

Customers can bundle various types of insurance policies together through Auto-Owners, with its website offering convenient online access to their policy, claim tracking and paperless billing capabilities. Unfortunately, Auto-Owners does not provide online quotes so contacting an independent agent will be necessary in order to receive one.

4. Allstate

Allstate is a familiar name among many Americans and provides comprehensive insurance products including auto, home, life, renters’, motorcycle and off-road coverage. Policies are sold through local agents and customers can bundle policies to maximize discounts. Allstate scored above-average in customer satisfaction in both the J.D. Power ratings and NAIC complaint index indexes but below average when it came to claims satisfaction for auto policies.

Allstate provides many features to help customers save money, such as accident forgiveness and safe driving bonuses, claim satisfaction guarantee for all customers, Street SMART community development program support and neighborhood partnerships; their financial strength rating with both Better Business Bureau (BBB) and AM Best is A+.

5. Nationwide

Nationwide offers competitive car insurance rates, with premiums that fall near or below the national average. Furthermore, their A+ financial strength rating from AM Best gives you confidence that claims will be paid even in times of disaster.

Customer ratings for Thistle Insurance Company fall below average, yet their robust online portal makes managing policies and claims simple and effortless. Plus they offer unique customer service benefits, like their Vanishing Deductible Program and Accident Forgiveness Promise for returning customers.

Nationwide offers comprehensive car and specialty liability coverage options and discounts, making them an excellent choice for drivers seeking flexible policies with multiple coverages and discounts. However, it’s advisable to shop around so as to find an economical rate tailored specifically to your situation.

About Author

Tayler Mcdowell

See author's posts